Week 2 - Authentic Instruction
Authentic Intellectual Work/Authentic Instruction & Assessment
Authentic Intellectual Work (AIW) is all about helping students do the kind of thinking and problem-solving they'd actually use in the real world. Instead of just memorizing facts or filling out worksheets, students are asked to dig deeper. They are tasked with making connections, solving real problems, and explaining their thinking clearly. Although this differs from traditional teaching, where the focus is usually on getting through the curriculum, preparing for standardized tests, or doing minimal activities that don't go beyond the classroom, AIW can be used in tandem with traditional teaching methods to create a more interactive and impactful lesson that integrates real-world problem solving and critical thinking. With AIW, it's not about the activity itself, but about whether it really pushes students to think in meaningful ways.
There are three main parts of AIW: construction of knowledge, disciplined inquiry, and value beyond school. The most important part in my opinion is "disciplined inquiry." This occurs when students use what they already know to explore bigger questions or ideas and explain their thinking in detail. This process goes beyond simply answering a question for answering's sake, but allows students to "show what they know" and demonstrate critical thinking skills. It also requires them to build on their communication skills and use "verbal, symbolic, graphic, and visual communication to provide qualifications, nuances, elaborations, justifications, and dialogue" (Newmann, King, & Carmichael, 2007).
A study conducted in Chicago from 1996-1999 aimed to assess how the quality of teachers' assignments were affected by the introduction of authentic assignments that helped students to construct knowledge, utilize disciplined inquiry, and apply value to their learning beyond school. The study found that "students receiving higher quality assignments gained about 20% more in basic skills than the Chicago average gain and almost 40% more than students receiving the lowest quality assignments." (Newmann et. al., 2007). This study proved that AIW-oriented assignments help students not only understand content better, but apply more of what they've learned to other skills and real-world scenarios.
In an alternative education setting, real world application and deep-diving of content is a must. It not only gets the students engaged and helps them apply what they've learned to their lives outside of school, but applies meaning and value to the lesson. For example, let’s say a teacher notices that students are disengaged with a typical economics lesson. Instead, the teacher might have students create a budget for living on minimum wage, which is an actual skill they may be using/will need to use. Students research rent, groceries, transportation, and other costs in their own city, then work out whether it’s possible to live on that income. They might even present their findings to classmates or a local community group. It also allows students with experience in budgeting to act as content experts and mentor others. This kind of project gets students thinking critically about real-life issues, using math and research skills, and communicating their ideas, which are all key parts of AIW. Plus, it feels real and relevant, which is super important in alternative education.
National Education Technology Plan - "Digital Use Divide"
The National Education Technology Plan provided by the US Department of Education is a guideline for educators to help them implement technology into their lesson plans and classroom environments. It provides techniques, best practices, and evidence-based research to make technology equitable and accessible for teachers and students. The "Digital Use Divide" section of this plan makes it clear that not just having access to technology, but how we use it is what's most important. Some students use technology to think critically, collaborate, and create things, while others are stuck filling out digital worksheets or watching videos without much interaction. This is a huge opportunity to bring in the components of AIW, and use technology to build knowledge, implement disciplined inquiry, and create work that has value beyond the classroom.
One clear way to close the digital use divide and support AIW is by designing learning experiences where students use technology to create, analyze, and share their work. For example, the plan recommends giving students more voice and choice by letting them co-design learning experiences and use tools that support Universal Design for Learning (UDL). UDL is a framework that aims to "make learning accessible and effective for all students by reducing barriers in instruction and addressing individual differences, learning preferences, abilities, and backgrounds" (U.S. Department of Education, 2024). This connects perfectly with AIW, especially the idea that students' work should be not only useful and valuable outside of school, but accessible and equitable.
For example, an alternative education teacher could use these principles and integrate them into project-based instruction, which is often a tenet of these programs due to the benefits of hands on learning. For a project related to environmental justice, a teacher could use UDL to make sure students can access the content in different ways. Some could read articles, others could watch documentaries or use simulations. Then, students can choose how to show what they’ve learned: maybe by recording a podcast, writing an article, creating a digital art piece, or building an infographic. One student might even interview a local activist over Zoom and create a mini-documentary. This kind of lesson covers all the bases, including multiple means of representation (videos, texts, interviews), multiple means of action and expression (students choosing how they show what they've learned), and multiple means of engagement (topic relevance, collaboration, student choice). It also meets the core ideas of AIW where students are building knowledge through inquiry, thinking deeply about real world issues, and creating products they could share with an authentic audience, like a community group or city council.
Comments
Post a Comment